Day #11 - Whiskey Advent Calendar

A busier than expected weekend has put me further behind schedule with the Advent calendar. On the upside, if I were on schedule, tonight's sample would be #19 leaving only five samples left to enjoy. Instead, my tardiness has left a whopping thirteen samples yet to be discovered, who says procrastination doesn't pay??

 

Jumping into the sample, and my short-term absence from the calendar is not being rewarded with a remarkable nose. Subtle vanilla, subtle barley sugar, subtle alcohol, you get the idea. With a bit of time, there is a cocoa powder note. All in all, there is not a whole lot going on here with the nose, it smells as though it is muted.

The taste is slightly more interesting than the nose, but not by much. Plenty of barley, very light oak, gentle red pepper spice. There is an initial burst of sweetness with the sip that morphs into a spicy sensation. The alcohol is well controlled here (or low strength).

The finish is medium length. As with the taste, the finish begins sweet but concludes with the red pepper spice.

All in all this is a perfectly fine whiskey, but not overly memorable. I do believe this is a barley-based whiskey. Perhaps a blend, but I do not get a lot of grain whiskey influence. Eliminating the possibility of grain whiskey means I am working with a 100% barley based whiskey here - perhaps a blend of different single malts? Yeah, let's go with that, a Scottish blended malt. I do not believe this has been aged terribly long, 8-10 years tops. Lastly, the alcohol is low, no higher than 43%, but I think 40% ABV is more likely. Overall, I am not too impressed, this whiskey could use a bit more strength to help liven its experience up.

My Guess

Type/Style: Blended Malt Scotch Whisky

Region: Scotland

Age: 8 to 10 years old

Maturation: Ex-bourbon

Strength: 40% ABV

Producer: Compass Box

Sip, Mix, or Skip?: Skip

 

Reveal

Name: The Irishman - The Harvest

Type/Style: Irish Blended Whiskey (70% Single Malt, 30% Irish Single Pot Still)

Region: Ireland

Age: Non-age stated

Maturation: Ex-bourbon

Strength: 40% ABV

Producer: Walsh Whiskey

Price: $33

Official Tasting Notes

The Irishman The Harvest is the first blend created by Bernard Walsh, and it is still one of their best and one of the most unique coming out of the Irish craft distilling market. It is a blend of 70% Single Malt and 30% Single Pot Still Spirits aged in ex-Bourbon casks. This twist on a classic adds a very nice layered complexity and a bit of grain spice that makes this dram a stand-out. It is also a multi-award-winner with Gold Medals dripping off the bottle like honey.

Pedantic Corner:
"Single Malt" is a distillation of 100% malted barley from a single distillery, "Single Pot Still" also comes from a single distillery, but the mash consists of a combination of malted and un-malted barley.

Final Thoughts

Ohhhhh, a blended Irish whiskey but a blend of only barley-based whiskeys! Tricky tricky and well played Advent calendar. In the world of whiskey, Single Pot Still Irish is arguably my favorite type of whiskey (I do vacillate on this topic, hence the 'arguably'). Typically a Single Pot Still Irish Whisky delivers an unmistakable aroma of fresh cut green grass, yet I did not detect any such smell from this whiskey. Granted, the single pot still portion is only 30% of the blend, however I am a tad disappointed in myself for missing that note.

 

On paper, this particular whiskey should be a home run. Blending together the two great barley-based whiskey styles of Ireland is a match made in heaven yet the actual whiskey in the bottle is a disappointment to me. For starters, I think this whiskey's low ABV truly hinders the experience from start to finish. A lack of character also dampens this whiskey leading to an overall 'meh' impression. A bit more strength and a bit more maturation time would do wonders for this blend I suspect. The concept is stellar, the implementation needs a bit of work however. Close, but no cigar for me; this whiskey is a 'skip'.